The legal battle for the Jubilee Hills Assembly seat has officially moved to the Telangana High Court, with Bharat Rashtra Samithi candidate Maganti Sunitha filing an election petition this Monday to challenge the recent bypoll results. Sunitha, who is the wife of former MLA Maganti Gopinath, is not just seeking to overturn the victory of Congress’s Naveen Yadav; she is asking the court to void his election entirely and declare her the duly elected representative instead.
The by-election, which saw a crowded field of 58 candidates, concluded in mid-November with Naveen Yadav winning by a margin of 24,729 votes. But the grounds raised in the petition filed by Sunitha state that the whole procedure was affected by violations of the Representation of the People Act. The root of her pleas lies with the obligatory disclosure of criminal records. She contends that Yadav was not able to give a complete and true account of the criminal antecedents required by the Election Commission. As such, the voters were denied the right to make an informed decision.
To support this assertion, the petition relies very heavily on precedents established by the Supreme Court on the matter of disclosing the legal history of a candidate as being an essence of "free and fair" elections. The argument presented is that any suppression or misstatement of such information isn't just a technical oversight— it’s a "corrupt practice" that undermines the integrity of the vote. Sunitha also pointed a finger at the election authorities, claiming the Returning Officer failed in their duty to ensure these transparency rules were strictly followed before the ballots were cast.
As of now, the High Court is in the process of scrutinising the petition. Once the initial paperwork is cleared, the case will be listed for a hearing before a single judge. For the residents of Jubilee Hills, this means the final word on who represents them may now rest with the judiciary rather than the initial vote count.
Also read: Telangana HC pulls up police over Sigachi blast probe
Follow us
