News Arena

Join us

Home
/

google-s-ai-overviews-can-you-trust-the-answers

Technology

Google’s AI Overviews: Can you trust the answers?

AI Overviews is like fast food that gets delivered through a drive-through window – it’s quick, hot and convenient, but not the healthiest choice.

News Arena Network - Washington D.C. - UPDATED: June 10, 2024, 03:26 AM - 6 mins read

AI Overviews is like fast food that gets delivered through a drive-through window – it’s quick, hot and convenient, but not the healthiest choice.

Google’s AI Overviews: Can you trust the answers?

Google has acknowledged issues with AI Overviews and said it has addressed them. But the concern remains: Can you really trust any answers you receive through this service?


If you have used Google lately and been lucky – or unlucky – enough to encounter an answer to your query rather than a bunch of links, you have been subjected to something called AI Overviews. This is a new core feature that Google has been rolling out, a move widely anticipated since the company’s experiments with its LaMDA large language model in 2021, and since OpenAI’s ChatGPT artificial intelligence chatbot rocketed to prominence in 2023.


This feature is yet another addition to the increasing number of add-ons and tools being integrated into search engines like Google. Some of the notable examples include knowledge graph-driven knowledge panels, which are used to populate relevant factual information in an infobox next to search results, and featured snippets, which are blurbs excerpted from a search result and provided before the link to that page.

 

But what’s different about AI Overviews is that they are not simply extracted from relevant sources but generated behind the scenes by Google’s generative AI technology. The company’s goal is to give you a personalised, on-demand answer instead of a standard set of documents or even an answer box matching your query.

 

This seems almost magical and potentially useful in many situations. After all, people use search engines primarily to find answers and not lists of documents. But there’s more to the picture.

 

My colleague Emily Bender and I have written about what search engine users need, want and have. We have shown that they want not only information but also the ability to discover, learn and question what they find. In other words, users have a wide range of situations and objectives, and compressing them down to a set of links or, worse, a single answer is problematic.

 

Bad advice 
These AI features vacuum up information from the internet and other available sources and spit out an answer based on how they are trained to associate words. A core argument against them is that they mostly remove from the equation the user’s judgment, agency and opportunity to learn.

 

This may be OK for many searches. Want a description of how inflation has affected grocery prices in the past five years, or a summary of what the European Union AI Act includes? AI Overviews can be a good way to cut through a lot of documents and extract those specific answers.

 

But people’s searching needs don’t end with factual information. They look for ideas, opinions and advice. Looking for suggestions about how to keep the cheese from sliding off your pizza? Google will tell you that you should add some glue to the sauce. Or wondering if running with scissors has any health benefits? Sure, Google will say, “it can also improve your pores and give you strength”.

 

While a reasonable user can understand that such outrageous answers are likely to be wrong, it’s hard to detect that for factual questions.

 

For example, while researching the faith of US presidents, Google’s AI Overviews gave the incorrect answer that Barack Obama is a Muslim. This misinformation was widely circulated and debunked years ago, but Google regurgitated it with no good way for users to learn that it is misinformation.

 

What about a student using Google for homework and asking which countries in Africa start with the letter K? While Kenya does meet this criteria, Google’s AI Overviews incorrectly answered that there are no such countries.

 

Google has acknowledged issues with AI Overviews and said it has addressed them. But the concern remains: Can you really trust any answers you receive through this service?

 

How to avoid AI answers

There are alternatives. You can always go back to the traditional Google search with its 10 blue links. Click on “More” in the menu – All, News, Images, Maps, Videos and More – directly below the search field at the top of the Google search page and select “Web.” You can then do what you have likely done for decades now – sift through some of the top results, visit a few of those sites and decide for yourself.

 

It does take a little work, but it gives you back the ability to examine multiple sites and evidence to support or refute something. More importantly, you leave open the possibilities for learning, discovery and serendipity.

 

AI Overviews is like fast food that gets delivered through a drive-through window – it’s quick, hot and convenient, but not the healthiest choice.

 

Going through Google’s traditional search results is like examining a menu in a sit-down restaurant and placing an order that will take awhile to make it to your table.

 

You can ask your server questions about those items and even request some changes to the restaurant’s offerings. It’s prepared with more care, customisation and control, but also takes longer and may cost more.

 

These aren’t the only methods of finding information, however. There are alternatives to Google’s search engine, including specialty search tools.

 

For scholarly needs, Google Scholar, Semantic Scholar and CORE are helpful places to look for research papers and citations. Looking for medical information? Try PubMed, ScienceDirect and OpenMD. For legal needs, some services include Fastcase, Caselaw Access Project and CourtListener.
Concerned about privacy? Check out DuckDuckGo, Startpage and Swisscows.

 

If you still want AI-generated answers, some of the alternatives to Google’s AI Overviews and rival Bing’s Copilot are You.com and Komo, which provide more transparency about the data they collect about you, provide greater privacy and also offer ways to opt out of having your data collected for training their AI models.

 

A balanced information diet

Perhaps you can’t afford to eat out at a nice restaurant or prepare every meal from scratch every time, but it’s important to avoid ending up going through a drive-through for all your nourishment. After all, you are what you eat, and in a similar vein, you are how you search.


It’s easy to fall for sensational headlines and bite-size news that lack context. But you don’t have to let that define you. You can expand the scope of how you search. It’s OK to hit the drive-through every now and then and go for AI Overviews, but it’s important to also find other more wholesome ways to fulfil your needs – for food and for information.

 

(By arrangement with PTI/The Coversation/Chirag Shah, Professor of Information Science, University of Washington) 

Related News
Jony Ive, the renowned former chief design officer at Apple, recently shared his experiences of working under the leadership of Steve Jobs, calling it the most extraordinary time of his life.

Jony Ive reflects on joyful years with Steve Jobs

July 4, 2024, 04:14 AM - 2 mins read

Microsoft Corp has agreed to pay $14 million to settle allegations from a California agency that the company unlawfully penalized employees who took medical or family-care leave, as announced by the California Civil Rights Department on Wednesday.

Microsoft to pay $14M in leave penalty settlement

July 4, 2024, 01:39 AM - 2 mins read

Union Minister for IT and Electronics, Ashwini Vaishnaw, announced on Wednesday that discussions regarding regulations for Artificial Intelligence (AI) are currently underway, stressing the necessity of achieving a political consensus.

Vaishnaw stresses need for political consensus on AI

July 3, 2024, 08:06 AM - 2 mins read

UBS is experiencing a transformation in client interactions driven by artificial intelligence, according to Sabine Keller-Busse, head of the Swiss bank's domestic business.

AI drives new client proposals at UBS

July 2, 2024, 06:27 AM - 1 min read

In picture: Xenophrys apatani, named after Arunachal Pradesh's Apatani tribe, known for their conservation efforts in Arunachal Pradesh's Lower Subansiri Valley.

ZSI discovers new species of horned frog in Arunachal

July 2, 2024, 04:40 AM - 2 mins read

BITS Pilani announces a five-year research agreement with Mercedes-Benz India for advancing technology solutions and academic collaboration.

BITS Pilani, Mercedes-Benz ink 5-year research deal

July 1, 2024, 04:15 AM - 2 mins read

India to send astronauts with SERA, Blue Origin's astronaut program

India to send astronauts with SERA, Blue Origin

July 1, 2024, 01:37 AM - 2 mins read

Google announced it has taken a stake in Taiwan's New Green Power (NGP) and could purchase up to 300 megawatts of renewable energy from the BlackRock fund-owned firm.

Google invests in NGP to cut carbon emissions

July 1, 2024, 01:28 AM - 2 mins read

OpenAI unveils CriticGPT to improve GPT-4

OpenAI unveils CriticGPT to improve GPT-4

June 29, 2024, 01:40 AM - 2 mins read

https://www.instagram.com/thelaughclubofficial/
https://www.instagram.com/burraahhh_/

Technology

See All
Jony Ive, the renowned former chief design officer at Apple, recently shared his experiences of working under the leadership of Steve Jobs, calling it the most extraordinary time of his life.

Jony Ive reflects on joyful years with Steve Jobs

July 4, 2024, 04:14 AM - 2 mins read

Ive, who joined Apple at the young age of 25, played a pivotal role in designing iconic products like the MacBook, iPhone, iPad, Apple Watch, and AirPods. Alongside Jobs, he transformed Apple from a struggling company into a global leader in innovation and design. Ive left Apple in 2019 to start his own design firm, LoveFrom, based in San Francisco.

Read more
Microsoft Corp has agreed to pay $14 million to settle allegations from a California agency that the company unlawfully penalized employees who took medical or family-care leave, as announced by the California Civil Rights Department on Wednesday.

Microsoft to pay $14M in leave penalty settlement

July 4, 2024, 01:39 AM - 2 mins read

The department claimed that these workers, who were predominantly women and people with disabilities, were denied raises, promotions, and stock awards. Additionally, they received lower performance-review scores, which negatively impacted their pay, career advancement opportunities, and overall career trajectory.

Read more
Cloud resources biggest targets for cyberattacks in India: Study

Cloud resources biggest targets for cyberattacks in India

July 3, 2024, 08:47 PM - 5 mins read

In India, nearly half of the respondents reported that all corporate data stored in the cloud is sensitive and 37 per cent of the participating organisations have experienced a cloud data breach.

Read more
Union Minister for IT and Electronics, Ashwini Vaishnaw, announced on Wednesday that discussions regarding regulations for Artificial Intelligence (AI) are currently underway, stressing the necessity of achieving a political consensus.

Vaishnaw stresses need for political consensus on AI

July 3, 2024, 08:06 AM - 2 mins read

Speaking at the 'Global IndiaAI Summit', Minister Vaishnaw highlighted the importance of societal understanding of both the potential and threats posed by AI. "All sections of society must fully understand the threats and potential of Artificial Intelligence only then we should approach legal action," he told reporters.

Read more
A recent assessment highlights the vast gap India must bridge to match the capabilities of other leading nations in quantum technologies, despite launching a National Quantum Mission worth ₹6,000 crores to develop key future technologies. 

India faces quantum tech challenge despite ₹6,000 cr mission

July 3, 2024, 01:31 AM - 3 mins read

“It is commendable that India is among the 17 countries with formal national quantum missions and is among the top 12 countries in terms of committed investments. At the same time, we must recognize that India is lagging behind the global leaders in quantum technologies and needs to ramp up both R&D and translational aspects to catch up with them,” the assessment said.

Read more
Image for representative use only.

Aditya-L1 completes initial halo orbit around Sun-Earth L1

July 2, 2024, 08:10 AM - 2 mins read

Launched on September 2, 2023, the Aditya-L1 mission aims to observe the sun from the advantageous Lagrangian point L1.

Read more
UBS is experiencing a transformation in client interactions driven by artificial intelligence, according to Sabine Keller-Busse, head of the Swiss bank's domestic business.

AI drives new client proposals at UBS

July 2, 2024, 06:27 AM - 1 min read

Speaking at the Point Zero Forum in Zurich on Tuesday, Keller-Busse compared this shift to how patients approach doctors with preformed ideas about their ailments, now clients are using AI to generate proposals for the bank.

Read more
In picture: Xenophrys apatani, named after Arunachal Pradesh's Apatani tribe, known for their conservation efforts in Arunachal Pradesh's Lower Subansiri Valley.

ZSI discovers new species of horned frog in Arunachal

July 2, 2024, 04:40 AM - 2 mins read

Named Xenophrys apatani after Arunachal Pradesh's Apatani tribe, known for their conservation efforts in the Lower Subansiri Valley, the species exhibits unique genetic and physical traits.

Read more
BITS Pilani announces a five-year research agreement with Mercedes-Benz India for advancing technology solutions and academic collaboration.

BITS Pilani, Mercedes-Benz ink 5-year research deal

July 1, 2024, 04:15 AM - 2 mins read

According to a statement issued by the institute, the collaboration aims to establish a robust framework for joint research, fostering the creation of intellectual property in cutting-edge technology solutions and promoting academic collaboration. 

Read more
India to send astronauts with SERA, Blue Origin's astronaut program

India to send astronauts with SERA, Blue Origin

July 1, 2024, 01:37 AM - 2 mins read

The US-based Space Exploration and Research Agency (SERA) and Blue Origin announced India as a partner in their human spaceflight program, offering Indian citizens a chance to fly on Blue Origin’s reusable rocket, New Shepard, past the Karman line into space.

Read more
Google announced it has taken a stake in Taiwan's New Green Power (NGP) and could purchase up to 300 megawatts of renewable energy from the BlackRock fund-owned firm.

Google invests in NGP to cut carbon emissions

July 1, 2024, 01:28 AM - 2 mins read

Taiwan, a significant hub for Google's cloud technology with a data center and company offices, relies heavily on fossil fuels for nearly 85% of its power, according to Amanda Peterson Corio, Google's Global Head of Data Center Energy. "The goal of this investment is really to support the build-out of a large-scale solar pipeline in Taiwan," Corio told Reuters.

Read more
OpenAI unveils CriticGPT to improve GPT-4

OpenAI unveils CriticGPT to improve GPT-4

June 29, 2024, 01:40 AM - 2 mins read

CriticGPT is still in development and is not yet accessible to users or testers. Its objective is to improve the quality of AI-generated code.

Read more

TOP CATEGORIES

  • Nation

QUICK LINKS

About us Rss FeedSitemapPrivacy PolicyTerms & Condition
logo

2024 News Arena India Pvt Ltd | All rights reserved | The Ideaz Factory