News Arena

Join us

Home
/

ask-a-100-year-old-about-survival-the-answer-might-surprise-you

Health

Ask a 100-year-old about survival, the answer might surprise you

Survivorship bias is everywhere in society. We can all think of that one famous actor or entrepreneur who succeeded despite adversity, who worked hard, believed in themselves and one day made it. But we never read about or hear about the countless examples of people who tried, gave it their all and never quite made it.

News Arena Network - London - UPDATED: May 12, 2024, 06:36 AM - 5 mins read

Survivorship bias is everywhere in society. We can all think of that one famous actor or entrepreneur who succeeded despite adversity, who worked hard, believed in themselves and one day made it. But we never read about or hear about the countless examples of people who tried, gave it their all and never quite made it.

Ask a 100-year-old about survival, the answer might surprise you

With some people lifelong exercise is associated with their unusually good health into older age, but we can’t directly say one causes the other yet. (For representation).


It’s a cliche of reporting on people who reach 100 years of age, or even 110, to ask them some variation of the question: “What did you do to live this long?”

 

While a popular news story, this is a relatively meaningless question that doesn’t help us understand why certain people have lived so long. Let's try to explain why, via beautiful buildings, fighter pilots and statistics.

 

In the second world war, Allied statisticians were applying their skills to minimising the number of bombers being shot down by enemy fire. By studying the damage patterns of bombers returning from action, maps could be drawn up of the most frequently damaged parts of aeroplanes so that expensive, heavy armour could be added to these areas.

 

Simple enough, right? Then, along comes statistician Abraham Wald who argues for the exact opposite point. The planes that they’re studying are all those that did return from combat with extensive damage, but what about those that didn’t return?

 

Wald who argues for the exact opposite point. The planes that they’re studying are all those that did return from combat with extensive damage, but what about those that didn’t return? Wald argues that armour should be added to those places that are undamaged on all the returning planes, as any plane hit in these undamaged areas was shot down, never making it back to be surveyed.

 

This phenomenon is known as survivorship bias, or the cognitive and statistical bias introduced by only counting those that are around to count but ignoring those that haven’t “survived”.

 

You can take these examples to the absurd. Imagine a group of 100 people, all of whom have smoked their entire life. As a group, the smokers would die earlier of cancers, lung disease or heart disease, but one or two might defy the odds and live to 100 years of age.

 

Now imagine the intrepid journalist interviewing the lucky soul on their 100th birthday with that classic question: “What do you attribute your successful ageing to?” 

 

“Smoking a pack a day,” says the newly minted centenarian.

 

It seems obvious but survivorship bias is everywhere in society. We can all think of that one famous actor or entrepreneur who succeeded despite adversity, who worked hard, believed in themselves and one day made it. But we never read about or hear about the countless examples of people who tried, gave it their all and never quite made it.

 

That’s not a good media story. But this creates a bias, we primarily hear the successes, never the failures. This bias applies to our perceptions of architecture (mostly great buildings from a given period “survive”), to finances (we often hear examples of people who have succeeded in risky investments, those who fail don’t sell books or self-help plans) and to career plans (“If you work hard, and drop out of college now, you can be a successful athlete like me,” say those who have succeeded).

 

I work with a variety of older people and often include extreme outliers who have lived to extreme ages. We’re currently studying over 65-year-olds who have maintained unusually high levels of exercise into older age and have maintained excellent health.

 

They’re phenomenal examples of older humans, many of them are faster, fitter and stronger than me by many of the measures we perform in the lab, despite being almost twice my age.

 

While we know that their lifelong exercise is associated with their unusually good health into older age, we can’t directly say one causes the other yet. It could be that highly active people are protected against chronic diseases such as cancers, diabetes and heart disease. But it also could be that these people are still active into older age as they’ve not been afflicted by cancers, diabetes or heart disease earlier in their lives.

 

Conversely, there could be some unknown third factor that we’ve not yet identified about these people that both keeps them healthy and separately keeps them exercising.

 

For clarity, there are things that scientists like me will say in carefully caveated, scientific language that will probably help you to live longer. Being very physically active, not eating too much and not smoking are all on that list, along with generally having a positive outlook in life, and of course, picking the right parents and grandparents.

 

Correlation does not equal causation. That point is hammered home relentlessly to students in science degrees. It’s how our brain works, we see a pattern between two variables, and assume they’re linked in some way. But often, like in survivorship bias, we’re not looking at all the data, and so finding patterns where there are none.

 

(The author Bradley Elliott is a Senior Lecturer in Physiology, University of Westminster. By arrangement with PTI and The Conversation) 

Related News
Extreme temperatures, both low and high, and greater changes over the course of the day -- driven by climate change -- were shown to have an impact on brain diseases, explained lead researcher Sanjay Sisodiya from the University of College London's Institute of Neurology, UK.

Climate change likely to impact people with brain conditions, study finds

May 17, 2024, 08:57 PM - 3 mins read

https://www.instagram.com/thelaughclubofficial/
https://www.instagram.com/burraahhh_/

Health

See All
Extreme temperatures, both low and high, and greater changes over the course of the day -- driven by climate change -- were shown to have an impact on brain diseases, explained lead researcher Sanjay Sisodiya from the University of College London's Institute of Neurology, UK.

Climate change likely to impact people with brain conditions, study finds

May 17, 2024, 08:57 PM - 3 mins read

Extreme temperatures, both low and high, and greater changes over the course of the day -- driven by climate change -- were shown to have an impact on brain diseases, explained lead researcher Sanjay Sisodiya from the University of College London's Institute of Neurology, UK.

Read more
A cabin air analysis of electric, gas and hybrid cars manufactured between 2015 and 2022 showed that 99 per cent cars contained a flame retardant called TCIPP, which could be a carcinogen.

You could be breathing in carcinogens in your car: Study

May 9, 2024, 06:39 AM - 2 mins read

A cabin air analysis of electric, gas and hybrid cars manufactured between 2015 and 2022 showed that 99 per cent cars contained a flame retardant called TCIPP, which could be a carcinogen.

Read more
There is growing evidence that sedentary children are likely to have health problems and it 'needs to be taken seriously'.

Childhood sedentary life could be associated with heart enlargement, study reveals

May 8, 2024, 03:18 AM - 3 mins read

There is growing evidence that sedentary children are likely to have health problems and it 'needs to be taken seriously'.

Read more
Apart from fever, some patients also report headache, vomiting and itching. In very few instances, of 1 per cent, brain damage resulting in loss of consciousness and sometimes death is reported, State Health Minister Veena George confirmed in a statement.

West Nile fever cases reported in Kerala, state govt issues safety instructions

May 7, 2024, 05:06 AM - 3 mins read

Apart from fever, some patients also report headache, vomiting and itching. In very few instances, say 1 per cent, brain damage resulting in loss of consciousness and sometimes death is reported, State Health Minister Veena George confirmed in a statement.

Read more
Gym-goers in India face surge in sudden heart attacks, killing at least 4 in 24 hrs

Gym-goers in India face surge in sudden heart attacks, killing at least 4 in 24 hrs

May 2, 2024, 07:18 AM - 3 mins read

In light of recent instances of sudden heart attacks claiming lives in India, health experts are urging gym enthusiasts, especially those in their mid-30s and 40s, to undergo thorough medical evaluations before commencing their exercise regimens.

Read more
Manufacturing license of Patanjali Divya Pharmacy’s ten products suspended

Manufacturing license of Patanjali Divya Pharmacy’s ten products suspended

April 29, 2024, 07:40 PM - 1 min read

The firm did not provide the information sought from it regarding the products and the explanation offered by it in its defence was not satisfactory, the Uttarakhand Drug licensing authority said in its order.

Read more
Haidt's new book underlines risks teenagers face because of excessive phone use and less time spent interacting with peers and family, but you don't have to believe it all...

Take that mobile phone away from your teenager, says social psychologist Jonathan Haidt

April 29, 2024, 05:11 AM - 10 mins read

Haidt's new book underlines risks teenagers face because of excessive phone use and less time spent interacting with peers and family, but you don't have to believe it all...

Read more
Childhood dementia treatments currently under evaluation or approved are for a very limited number of disorders, and are only available in some parts of the world.

Lack of funding, research hampering efforts to treat childhood dementia

April 28, 2024, 05:18 AM - 4 mins read

Childhood dementia treatments currently under evaluation or approved are for a very limited number of disorders, and are only available in some parts of the world.

Read more
Sunday evening’s big fire at the Ghazipur landfill on Monday, which sent toxic plumes of smoke and pollution levels skywards, is not something new. Smaller fires keep breaking out frequently at the dump, leaving the area shrouded in smoke and stench.

Ghazipur landfill: Health problems increasing, surge likely after fire, says pulmonologist

April 22, 2024, 07:26 PM - 4 mins read

These fires, fuelled by methane gas generated from decomposing waste at the site, as well as hot and dry conditions, spew out toxins that keep pollution levels at an all-time high in the Anand Vihar-Ghaziabad areas close by, resulting in health complications on which no data has been collected or researched so far.

Read more
'Most common' breast cancer to cause a million annual deaths by 2040: Lancet

'Most common' breast cancer to cause a million annual deaths by 2040: Lancet

April 15, 2024, 09:39 PM - 2 mins read

A new study by Lancet has found breast cancer is now the world's most common carcinogenic disease, with the ailment likely to cause a million deaths a year by 2040.

Read more
Ayushman Bharat- over five years later, is the scheme a success?

Ayushman Bharat 2.0: A game-changer for India’s health sector?

April 15, 2024, 06:30 AM - 6 mins read

India took a significant stride towards ensuring access to quality healthcare, regardless of economic status by launching the flagship health protection scheme, Ayushman Bharat Pradhan Mantri Jan Arogya Yojana (AB-PMJAY), in September 2018. 

Read more

TOP CATEGORIES

  • Nation

QUICK LINKS

About us Rss FeedSitemapPrivacy PolicyTerms & Condition
logo

2024 News Arena India Pvt Ltd | All rights reserved | The Ideaz Factory